My son and I will go for a pizza and a slice, but we only sit on the takeout side now. Obviously, it isn't family friendly, and they just want that side as a neighbourhood bar. The bartender / waitress didn't take our order, and each time we got up and left to go elsewhere.

My wife and I have tried going in with the kids on 3 separate occasions, and were ignored. The bar / restaurant side is another story, and its hard to give an overall rating because of that.

The takeout side staff is always friendly. The slice and pop deal for $3.99 is always great. When ordering, make sure you try their 'Cat Tails', which are deep fried dough, with a caramel sauce and confectioner sugar. The wings are good, and calzones are excellent. When she's not working, its still good but not great. On the takeout side, when the manager is working, this is the best pizza you'll have. Would I go here again? If it was the only option, probably. Grocery store pizza level quality to be honest. Seemed pre-made or possibly frozen crust. It didn't taste like it was scratch made dough and rolled out to order. They definitely weren't fried in the frier until crispy and doused in Buffalo sauce like they should be.

I honestly don't believe they know how to prepare wings in Canada. I had gotten wings the previous night at another nearby place and they were the same type of wings. They seemed to be flavored with a dry rub or something then cooked in the oven. They had been flavored somehow but were definitely not 'saucy' or crispy for that matter. Got back to the hotel and opened the wings first.

That's the traditional 'Buffalo' sauce that you find in the States. I ordered the wings off the menu as what was described as 'new york style' with the description of that being hot sauce and butter. I ordered their special of a 10' pizza and a pound of wings and added a second 10' pizza also. Went there in a snowstorm to get wings and pizza because I was in town for the Ice Wine Festival and due to the snow, nothing else was nearby. So, i was recommended this place for their 'amazing' wings.

Fat cats pizza review